A bad year for Asian air travel

[Freude am Fahren]

Pilot is a hero for avoiding buildings and roads... Hence the sharp banking into the river.

Black box is showing pilot made an error for shutting off the wrong engine... Resulting loss of power of both engines after takeoff.

You can't fuck up, then be called a hero just for not killing as many people as possible.

[Crazed_Insanity]

The plane fucked up first. This particular airline with this particular model has crashed way too often. I find it too convinient to all be pilot error.

[Crazed_Insanity]

Pilots were found with face crushed, legs broken, but hands firmly gripping the steering controls... Presumably trying to steer clear of buildings and roads...

[Random]

The plane fucked up first. This particular airline with this particular model has crashed way too often. I find it too convinient to all be pilot error.

Having an engine flame out is definitely not the pilots' fault. Pulling back power on the wrong engine is 100% on the pilots, however.

[The359]

Pilots were found with face crushed, legs broken, but hands firmly gripping the steering controls... Presumably trying to steer clear of buildings and roads...

I'm fairly certain the pilots hands would be on the controls no matter what sort of situation they'd be in. That is sort of his job.

[thesameguy]

Yeah, it's only boat captains that have the luxury of running.

Amirite?

[Crazed_Insanity]

Any pilots here? Why is it necessary to shut off the bad engine? (And risk shutting off the wrong engine during takeoff?) couldn't one wait until the plane is safely in flight to worry about that stupid useless engine?

[Random]

That's exactly what the protocol is, according to pilots on other sites: fly the airplane on the good engine until you're at a safe altitude/airspeed and then figure out what's going on with the bad engine. The flight data that's been released show that the auto-throttle program tried to do just that--it ran the good engine up to 100% power (from the 90% setting it was at) and also shut down the bleed air to maximize power.

[Crazed_Insanity]

Just read from another article saying that pilots may be trying restarting the engine by shutting it off first... But instead trying to 'restart' the wrong engine!