I think it's clear that their hiring process is questionable when reporters dug up info that the uber driver had a checkered past...
It's also obvious uber/volve/driver are mostly to blame even when the pedestrian j-walked, possibly in the dark...
Still, I'm not sure which video reflected the actual situation better. Original uber video looks way too dark and your youtube video looks way too bright... almost like we can clearly see even without turning on head lights!
Anyway, like I said, regardless of which video is more realistic, uber/volve shares most of the blame. I do hope they figure out and learn something out of this incident rather than just get shut down...